Skip to main content
Public holding company

Public holding company

Peter Gowan

Peter Gowan

Senior Policy Associate, The Next System Project more

Democratic Ownership Community & Place

A public holding company is a publicly owned enterprise that takes full or partial ownership in firms for economic stability and development purposes.

Firms are a complex nexus of relations between owners, workers, suppliers, customers, and the wider community and natural world. When a firm faces economic challenges or the threat of liquidation, the effects can ripple destructively through the community. In such cases, public holding companies could take an either partial or full ownership position in distressed firms to prevent the economic and social dislocations associated with liquidation or collapse. They are being proposed in various countries during the COVID-19 crisis to take equity stakes in threatened firms (especially small and medium-sized enterprises) that will later be divested when the crisis has abated. More innovative proposals envision using the holding company to transition firms to more democratic forms of ownership, such as cooperatives, employee share ownership, or social ownership, after the crisis has passed. The public holding company model is applicable to governments at all levels and wherever there are sufficient resources to establish and capitalize such a company.

Potential Impact

It is simply unnecessary that a temporary pandemic should lead to the permanent closure of countless firms that would have all the elements required for success but for such COVID-19-specific issues as health-mandated closure orders, a lack of demand due to social distancing, or supply chain disruptions. If properly structured, countless companies that have huge and often unquantifiable amounts of intangible knowledge, relationships with suppliers and industry know-how, and experienced teams of workers could be preserved as going concerns instead of failing or being bought up and asset-stripped by vulture capitalists and large corporations. Moreover, because many of these firms are currently experiencing economic difficulty, the government could purchase equity stakes at a discount. Simply by maintaining the firms until they are viable again, the holding company would make its investments back many times over.

Transformative Characteristics

A public holding company offers the potential not just to rescue viable businesses during and after the pandemic and ensure community economic stability, but it can make transformational changes in the businesses and their structure. The holding company can prioritize worker and community ownership in its exit strategies and can also promote transformed business practices that are more sustainable and focused on public needs, rather than extractive profits. If ownership shares are returned to individual local owners, a preference should be made for owners who are people of color, women, and veterans. While the pandemic is a serious crisis, it is only one of our interlinked social, economic, and ecological crises, and must be addressed alongside the pressing challenges of climate justice, racial injustice, and economic inequality. By using public holding companies, we could transform large parts of our economy to create a more democratic, sustainable, equal and reparative economy.

Examples

Reconstruction Finance Corporation

The Reconstruction Finance Corporation was established in 1932 and, after a period of exclusively making loans to banks, was transformed by the Roosevelt administration into an institution that authorized $13.2 billion in loans to agriculture, railroads, industry, public school authorities, state governments, federal agencies and other entities. During the New Deal, the RFC became the single largest investor in the country, owning shares (and often exercising voting rights) in thousands of U.S. companies. During World War II the RFC financed defense production and later supported the transition back to a peacetime economy. The RFC was wound down by the Eisenhower administration in 1957, having provided $50 billion in financing throughout its lifetime. It was essential to the economic recovery from the Great Depression, the war economy and the postwar economic expansion.

Temasek Holdings

Temasek Holdings is a state holding company owned by the Singapore government. It owned and managed a portfolio of over S$313 billion in 2019. Its investment decisions are governed by four key themes: transforming economies, growing middle-income populations, deepening Singapore’s comparative advantages and supporting emerging champion firms. While it is sometimes described as a sovereign wealth fund, unlike most such funds Temasek takes outright ownership of many firms and primarily invests in equities. Temasek is a permanent feature of the Singaporean economy and offers insight into how a state holding company established now could play a more permanent role in the democratic economy once the COVID-19 crisis is past.

Challenges

Some critics will focus on the perceived impropriety of the government “picking winners and losers.” But governments already make strategic economic choices in their crisis response strategies as well as in their everyday operations. Moreover, the COVID-19 crisis has created an exceptional situation where otherwise viable firms, especially small and medium-sized enterprises, are suffering due to temporary conditions imposed upon them. A public holding company with clear objectives, and transparent and accountable operations, would be a clear advance from the status quo of secretive public bailouts for the largest and most politically connected corporations, or efforts like the federal Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) that advantaged the most sophisticated and politically connected firms. Capitalization is a key challenge, especially for state and local governments whose budgets are hit hard by the pandemic’s effects. In such cases governments could redeploy existing economic development funds or pursue innovative methods to capitalize the holding company.

Download and Share

Peter Gowan

Peter Gowan

Senior Policy Associate, The Next System Project more

More related work

Stories

Public pharmaceutical

Public pharmaceuticals

Public pharmaceutical enterprises are free from the constraints of profit maximization and can define their bottom line based on such values as their contributions to public health and local economic resiliency. read more

Stories

Community development financial institution

Community development financial institutions

CDFIs are committed to providing services that create and broaden economic opportunities in neighborhoods that have faced historical disinvestment. read more

Stories

Low-income limited liability company

Low-profit limited liability companies

An L3C straddles the line between a nonprofit and for-profit venture, an enterprise with a profit goal that is subordinate to its charitable mission. read more

Stories

Participatory budgeting

Participatory budgeting

Participatory budgeting democratizes public investment by giving people the power to decide how public dollars are spent. read more

Stories

Credit union

Credit unions

Credit unions are financial cooperatives owned by their account holders and can concentrate on maximizing their impact in the community and on the financial well-being of their members. read more

Stories

Element of the Democratic Economy: Social Wealth Fund

Social wealth fund

A social wealth fund embraces the collective ownership of assets to provide services and democratically distribute resources within a society or community. read more

Stories

Worker cooperative

Worker cooperatives

A worker cooperative provides for both democratic ownership and democratic governance of the workplace, unlike traditional businesses in which ownership is often antagonistic to the workers who create value for the firm. read more

Stories

Municipal enterprise

Municipal enterprise

Municipal enterprises are businesses or services owned by local public authorities that provide services or generate revenue for local communities. read more

Stories

Employee stock ownership plan

Employee stock ownership plan

Description An employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) enables full or partial ownership of a business by its employees through a pension plan or trust. The first ESOP was created in 1956 by a San F read more

Stories

Element of the democratic economy: Public bank

Public Banks

How financial institutions owned by and accountable to the people help create a nonextractive economy. read more

Stories

The commons

The Commons

The commons are collective resources—encompassing things as varied as land, seed banks, and open-source software—managed by self-organized social systems under mutually acceptable terms. read more

Stories

Land bank – Elements of a Democratic Economy

Land Bank

Land banks can acquire abandoned, foreclosed, and tax-delinquent properties in order to convert them into productive use. read more

Stories

Community Land Trust

CLTs are nonprofit organizations that acquire and steward land in a “trust” for the permanent benefit of low-income communities. read more

Stories

Green Bank

Green Bank

A green bank can help communities transition away from fossil fuels and build resilience against climate change. read more

Stories

Community benefit agreement

Community Benefit Agreement

A legally binding product of negotiations between a developer and community members who have banded together to safeguard their community’s interests. read more

Stories

Resident-Owned Community

Resident-owned communities (ROCs) are manufactured housing neighborhoods (sometimes referred to as mobile home or trailer parks) in which the land is community-owned and managed. read more

Stories

Limited Equity Housing Cooperative

A limited equity housing cooperative is a residential development owned and managed by a democratically governed, nonprofit cooperative corporation, such as a tenants’ union. read more

Stories

Democratic energy utility

Democratic Energy Utility

Democratic energy utilities are nonprofits run by the public or community members in a way that enables their engagement in decision-making and distributes ownership. read more