Skip to main content
Gar Alperovitz

Gar Alperovitz

Co-Chair of The Next System Project more

Community & Place Democratic Ownership

Why is culture a key part of the pluralist commonwealth?

Too often, proposals for political economic alternatives rest on a mistaken assumption that with the correct laws, policies, and mechanisms, the desired results will automatically follow. This was a classic error, for instance, in the more “vulgar” Marxisms, which advanced a belief that transformations in the material “base”—i.e. the economic institutions of a society—would necessarily be represented by corresponding transformations in the “superstructure”—society’s ideology and cultural framework. This basic mistake is also widespread in a variety of technocratic interventions and proposals, all assuming that the right institutional design is sufficient to achieve the desired sociopolitical end. It is one of the failings of the contemporary US left that it has to a large extent ceded the territory of economic culture to the right—whose image of self-reliant, independent, proud participants in a capitalist system, however ultimately flawed and myopic, at least provides a coherent worldview in which people can recognize themselves as economic subjects.

The Pluralist Commonwealth vision, on the other hand, recognizes the importance of culture, and insists that any systemic design capable of guaranteeing equitable and sustainable outcomes needs to account for the way in which a community sustaining culture can both be independently nourished and also woven into the patterns created by community institutions.

Take worker ownership, for instance. As the well-studied experience of plywood cooperatives of the Pacific Northwest—in which the shares of workers were sold to outside investors or new members were hired as non-participating wage workers—showed, there is nothing intrinsic to democratic OWNERSHIP that checks a tendency to maximize profit at the expense of the community or even the long-term future wellbeing of the workers themselves. What is required—and what many contemporary worker cooperative advocates fully understand—is that the basic institutions of cooperative ownership need to be enmeshed in a cultural framework that establishes norms of racial and economic justice.

Another example comes from PLANNING. In the Pluralist Commonwealth, nonprofit and public institutions and policies are the non-market mechanisms used to achieve the kind of community stability that makes ecological and community-nurturing sense. But will the mere existence of the capacity for planning (i.e. planners and a legal/political framework) ensure ecologically sane outcomes? On the contrary, without democratic control, the development of a general culture of ecological responsibility, and planners committed to and educated within such a culture, there is nothing to suggest that the new plans will be the right ones.

What are the most important strategies for building such a culture?

It is first helpful to recognize that the project of creating and nourishing a culture capable of supporting and animating a Pluralist Commonwealth is equivalent to the establishment of a new common sense. While oppositional cultures, grounded in resistance and antagonism, certainly have a role to play in mobilizing popular movements for equity and justice, a true systemic alternative will very likely depend on changing the basic understanding of society, the economy, and ideas like COMMUNITY and LIBERTY for everyone. In other words, while calling out injustice and capitalism’s many failures is critical, if cultural interventions serve only to reinforce the camp of the righteous, whose identification depends on a corresponding identification of the wicked, we may be trading short-term ideological energy for long-term cultural gridlock. Our task, however difficult, is to imagine a new AMERICA, not to narrowly mobilize one other camp within it. Practically speaking, this means at the very least exploring methods of framing our ideological interventions whenever possible in ways which do not reinforce existing divides, but rather which undermine and transform the deeper layers of “common sense” presuppositions that currently forestall the emergence of new structural possibilities.

What are some examples of the development of the cultural transformations toward democratic society at work today?

BALLE—the Business Alliance for Local Living Economies—is an interesting example of the kind of cultural organizing needed to support the emergence of a Pluralist Commonwealth. Small business, for many orthodox anti-capitalists, represents only a petty bourgeois stratum, at best neutral in the class struggle. What BALLE, founded in 2001, understands is that there is in many (but certainly not all) small local businesses a commitment to place, a connection to community, distrust of large corporations and banks, relative insulation from the more extreme dynamics of the public capital markets that is compatible with and indeed desirable in a next system.1

Many if not most small businesspeople are also open to and supportive of cooperative and other commonwealth institutions. What BALLE provides is a framework that, by lifting up and connecting forward-thinking local entrepreneurs, helps shift the discourse around “business” towards an alternative systemic vision, built around shared values centered in community and ecological sustainability. A related national effort is that of the American Sustainable Business Alliance, which stresses social and ecological responsibility, does battle at the national level with the National Chamber of Commerce and other organizations dominated by major corporate power, and which supported unions against the attacks of Governor Scott Walker in Wisconsin.2

A deeper example is the work of the late Grace Lee Boggs to help the Detroit communities she called home for decades collectively experience pathways to postindustrial survival. For Boggs, the process of social transformation necessarily depended on personal and community transformations, materially changing the basic orientations of everyday life while simultaneously creating a new “structure of feeling.”3

Small practices—like the gardens underpinning a decentralized vision of urban food sovereignty—provide the scaffold on which this double transformation unfolds.

See also:

AMERICA, COMMUNITY, LIBERTY, OWNERSHIP, PLANNING

Further reading

Antonio Gramsci, Selections from the Prison Notebooks (New York, NY: International Publishers, 1971).

David Morley and Kuan-Hsing Chen, Stuart Hall: Critical Dialogues in Cultural Studies (New York, NY: Routledge, 1996).

Edward S. Greenberg, Workplace Democracy: The Political Effects of Participation (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1986).

Grace Lee Boggs and Scott Kurashige, The Next American Revolution (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press 2012).

Keane Bhatt and Steve Dubb, Educate and Empower: Tools for Building Community Wealth (Takoma Park, MD: The Democracy Collaborative, August 10, 2015).

Raymond Williams, The Long Revolution (New York, NY: Broadview Press, 2001 [1961]).

Robert E. Lane, “From Politics to Industrial Democracy?” Polity, 17, no. 4(1985): 623-648.

  • 1. BALLE History,” BALLE, accessed November 3, 2016.
  • 2. “Issues,” American Sustainable Business Council, accessed November 3, 2016.
  • 3. Grace Lee Boggs (with Scott Kurashige), The Next American Revolution: Sustainable Activism for the Twenty-First Century (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2012).
Gar Alperovitz

Gar Alperovitz

Co-Chair of The Next System Project more

More related work

Principles of a Pluralist Commonwealth: Introduction

If the design of corporate capitalism is unable to sustain values of equality, genuine democracy, liberty, and ecological sustainability as a matter of inherent systemic architecture, what systemic ‘design’ might ultimately achieve and sustain these values? read more
trade

Trade

Why are current approaches to trade problematic? How would the Pluralist Commonwealth approach trade? What existing efforts point toward a sustainable and just trade regime? read more
Tech

Technology

How do modern researchers understand the deeper sources of economic abundance and technological change? How should the fruits of our common technological inheritance be distributed now and in future? How would the Pluralist Commonwealth deploy management of new technologies in new ways? read more
Regionalism

Regionalism

Why consider long term regional devolution of power? How might long term devolution to regionalist patterns operate in the Pluralist Commonwealth? What are some on-the-ground developments that suggest possibilities for the future of regionalism? read more
race

Race

Why must the United States confront its long history of systemic racism? How would the Pluralist Commonwealth begin to promote racial equality? What on-the-ground efforts can be seen working towards our future of collective liberation? read more
public

Public

Why are new forms of public economic institutions important at certain critical levels of scale in the Pluralist Commonwealth? What are the key challenges for public ownership? Where are communities organizing elements of public ownership in the economy? read more

Prehistory

Why is the idea of prehistory important for thinking about systemic change? Are we in the prehistory of genuine systemic change, the prehistory of a Pluralist Commonwealth? read more
Pluralism

Pluralism

Why is pluralism an important value for systemic design? What makes a pluralist commonwealth “pluralist,” and why are more complex forms sometimes important? Where can we see pluralism in action today? read more
Planning

Planning

What is the role of planning in our present economic system? How would planning function in the Pluralist Commonwealth? Where are new models of decentralized and more participatory planning being explored today? read more
Ownership

Ownership

Why is ownership a key determinant of system structure? How does the Pluralist Commonwealth democratize ownership? Where is ownership being transformed in the direction of a Pluralist Commonwealth today? read more
Money

Money

How is money created in the current system? How is money created in the Pluralist Commonwealth? Where can we see key elements of a new approach to monetary policy emerging today? read more

Markets

What’s wrong with markets, and why do we still need them? How does the Pluralist Commonwealth use markets to sustain communities? Where are examples of markets that remain subject to democratic control operative today? read more
Liberty

Liberty

What is liberty? Why must liberty be a central part of the design for the pluralist commonwealth? Where is a renewed conception of liberty being developed on the ground today? read more
Investment

Investment

Why is investment in the current system fundamentally undemocratic and unsustainable? How would a Pluralist Commonwealth democratize investment? Where is investment managed in more democratic directions today? read more

Gender

Why must we factor gender equity into the institutional design of the next political and economic system? What kinds of structures would a Pluralist Commonwealth use to support true gender equality? Where are important elements of a more gender equitable system being built today? read more

Evolutionary Reconstruction And Displacement

How do evolutionary reconstruction and displacement of corporate power differ from “countervailing” strategies of containment and regulation? Why are evolutionary reconstruction and displacement key strategic approaches in the building of a Pluralist Commonwealth? read more

Equality

Why is equality a key part of the Pluralist Commonwealth? How is movement towards equality achieved in the Pluralist Commonwealth? What examples prefigure equality as envisioned in the Pluralist Commonwealth? read more

Economic Growth

Why is growth a challenging problem? How Would the Pluralist Commonwealth Manage Growth? Where can we see on the ground efforts to tackle the growth question today? read more
Economic Change

Economic Change

How does economic change really occur locally and nationally? How, specifically, can we build upon the ways cities and states already foster the local economy to create the Pluralist Commonwealth? What are some examples of shifts toward greater democracy? read more

Ecological Sustainability

Why is pluralism necessary to guarantee ecologically sustainable ends? What are the key strategies for environmental protection in the Pluralist Commonwealth? What are some promising on the ground developments that point toward an ecologically sustainable Pluralist Commonwealth? read more

Democracy

What is democracy? How does the Pluralist Commonwealth build stronger foundations for democratic life? Where are more participatory systemic directions being prototyped and developed today? read more
Decentralization

Decentralization

Why is decentralization a key principle of system design? What are the limits of decentralization? What are some contemporary developments in the direction of decentralization? read more

Cooperatives

What are cooperatives? What role do cooperatives play in a Pluralist Commonwealth? Where else is this systemic direction for cooperatives being prototyped and explored today? read more

Community

Why is community important to the pluralist commonwealth? What are institutional mechanisms aimed at undergirding rather than undermining community in a Pluralist Commonwealth? What current developments point towards the restoration of community as a central category? read more

Commonwealth

What does it mean to hold wealth in common? Why is wealth held in common and democratized at various scales, so important for the design of a next system? What are some examples of how “common wealth” builds a “commonwealth” today? read more

Climate Change

What are the challenges presented by global climate change? How does the Pluralist Commonwealth tackle ecological threats such as climate change? What are some promising on the ground developments that point toward an ecologically sustainable Pluralist Commonwealth? read more
bureaucracy

Bureaucracy

Why is bureaucracy problematic? What can be done in a pluralist commonwealth to minimize necessary bureaucracy? What contemporary interventions or potential interventions illustrate democratic control of large-scale entities? read more

America

Why is the Pluralist Commonwealth an American system? What resources for a Pluralist Commonwealth can be found in the American tradition? read more