Skip to main content
Gar Alperovitz

Gar Alperovitz

Distinguished Next System Fellow more

Democratic Ownership Democracy & Governance

Why is pluralism an important value for systemic design?

There is no one-size-fits-all approach to building a community sustaining economy. From a purely practical standpoint, certain social functions need to be exercised at larger scales, and quite simply, this requires different forms of institutional design. We need small independent businesses, cooperatives, neighborhood enterprises, housing and land developments, municipal firms, and regional and national models of larger enterprise. The key principle is to embed DEMOCRACY in all these institutions in diverse ways, appropriate to their individual scales. This means envisioning a system that is fundamentally pluralist—and all the richer for it. Indeed, without plural mechanisms of participation in the democratic life of the community and the nation, individual liberty is crippled—only pluralism prevents a certain kind of democratic belonging from becoming mandatory, a democracy closed in on itself rather than a resilient one open to invention, experimentation, and LIBERTY. At the same time, coherent system shaping planning and decision-making must be organized in diverse ways and at diverse levels of scale.

A pluralist approach is also critical from the perspective of developing a transition strategy. If a systemic design were to be predicated entirely on, say, the “capture of state power” or the complete transformation of the economy into cooperatives, we would all be stuck in place as we waited for some hoped-for game-changing transformation to occur. Pluralism means we can let a thousand flowers bloom, developing diverse experiments in various laboratories of democracy. These different possible directions begin to knit alternatives together into a viable systemic mosaic.

What makes a pluralist commonwealth “pluralist,” and why are more complex forms sometimes important?

The core ideas of the Pluralist Commonwealth—plural forms of democratic ownership, on the one hand, and an emphasis on building from the bottom up, community by community, and only moving to larger scales when necessary, on the other—are critical to the overall systemic design.

In most instances, functional and scale requirements suggest the appropriate patterns for various forms of ownership . For instance, land tends to be managed best by a geographic unit (neighborhood or city). Some forms of industry are best suited to worker ownership, others by small scale private enterprise, and still others by larger public entities. City-wide functions, like electricity or broadband, suggest geographically based public utilities.

Although worker-owned cooperatives and self-managed firms are important elements of the model for small- and medium-sized firms, for larger intermediate scale firms the Pluralist Commonwealth stresses the importance of ownership forms that inherently integrate worker and community (neighborhood or municipal) concerns in more complex relationships. A major goal is to offset pressures that lead any firm, cooperative or privately held, to pollute the community environment if forced to under competitive pressure from other firms. Creating joint ownership forms with the community itself produces a model in which community representatives are required to choose between making a greater profit for both the community and workers by avoiding the cost of environmentally important processes—and accepting the environmental despoliation of the community such decisions produce. (In economic terms, such models “internalize decisions about externalities.”)

The Pluralist Commonwealth draws upon joint worker and community models as they were first proposed by steelworkers in Youngstown, Ohio—and which have been evolving in sophistication and complexity over time, in cities like Cleveland, Ohio and elsewhere. An important element in such integrated “community-worker” models is the application of principles drawn from the experience of the Mondragón Corporation to local geographic and community-building efforts.

The construction of airplanes of globe-spanning scale, high-speed railroad systems, satellite systems (and the rockets needed to put them in orbit) remind us of the importance of larger scale efforts and the likelihood of regional or national enterprise forms (jointly owned and managed, as appropriate, by the workers and communities actually doing the work). Contrary to earlier periods of history, in diverse parts of the world there are now numerous examples of effective forms of large scale public enterprises, ranging from the construction of the largest world-spanning aircraft to high speed rail and internet systems more efficient and faster than our own—forms which can be further refined as time goes on (See OWNERSHIP).

Where can we see pluralism in action today?

Efforts in Colorado, while still for the most part small in scale or tentative, are suggestive of a Pluralist Commonwealth direction. In Denver, immigrant households are creating small-scale, privately owned backyard food businesses, which are linked together within a larger multi-stakeholder cooperative structure called Re:Vision to handle distribution and retail.1 The Rocky Mountain Employee Ownership Center is supporting the formation of small and medium sized worker-owned enterprises, like the Namaste Solar cooperative.2 At the community level, a nonprofit, the Urban Land Conservancy, is developing strategies to hold valuable land near transit lines in trust to spur community development.3 At the city level, Boulder residents are remunicipalizing their electrical utility,4 and at the state level, steps toward a publicly-owned single payer health care cooperative have been taken. Colorado put the matter to a vote in November 2016.5 Unfortunately, the ballot measure didn’t pass. 6 None of these efforts precludes the others, and indeed, as principles of common, cooperative, and community-ownership become more deeply rooted, they may prove to be mutually reinforcing.

Elsewhere, as noted (See PUBLIC), the Evergreen Cooperatives in Cleveland, Ohio offer a model that integrates neighborhood and worker-ownership,7 in Rochester, New York, a related plan building on the Evergreen approach has been put forward for development by Mayor Lovely Warren.8 In Buffalo, New York, a community organizing effort, “PUSH BUFFALO,” has helped develop sustainable and affordable housing, decrease housing abandonment, jumpstart social enterprise to provide living wages for area residents, and created the Grant Street Neighborhood Center, a teen-oriented community center.9

See also:


Further reading

Keane Bhatt and Steve Dubb, Educate and Empower: Tools for Building Community Wealth, (Takoma Park, MD: The Democracy Collaborative, 2015).

Robert F Garnett Jr, Erik Olsen, Martha Starr, eds., Economic Pluralism (New York, NY: Routledge, 2010).

Steve Dubb, Conversations on Community Wealth Building (Washington, DC: Democracy Collaborative, 2016).

Gar Alperovitz

Gar Alperovitz

Distinguished Next System Fellow more

More related work

Principles of a Pluralist Commonwealth: Introduction

If the design of corporate capitalism is unable to sustain values of equality, genuine democracy, liberty, and ecological sustainability as a matter of inherent systemic architecture, what systemic ‘design’ might ultimately achieve and sustain these values? read more


Why are current approaches to trade problematic? How would the Pluralist Commonwealth approach trade? What existing efforts point toward a sustainable and just trade regime? read more


How do modern researchers understand the deeper sources of economic abundance and technological change? How should the fruits of our common technological inheritance be distributed now and in future? How would the Pluralist Commonwealth deploy management of new technologies in new ways? read more


Why consider long term regional devolution of power? How might long term devolution to regionalist patterns operate in the Pluralist Commonwealth? What are some on-the-ground developments that suggest possibilities for the future of regionalism? read more


Why must the United States confront its long history of systemic racism? How would the Pluralist Commonwealth begin to promote racial equality? What on-the-ground efforts can be seen working towards our future of collective liberation? read more


Why are new forms of public economic institutions important at certain critical levels of scale in the Pluralist Commonwealth? What are the key challenges for public ownership? Where are communities organizing elements of public ownership in the economy? read more


Why is the idea of prehistory important for thinking about systemic change? Are we in the prehistory of genuine systemic change, the prehistory of a Pluralist Commonwealth? read more


What is the role of planning in our present economic system? How would planning function in the Pluralist Commonwealth? Where are new models of decentralized and more participatory planning being explored today? read more


Why is ownership a key determinant of system structure? How does the Pluralist Commonwealth democratize ownership? Where is ownership being transformed in the direction of a Pluralist Commonwealth today? read more


How is money created in the current system? How is money created in the Pluralist Commonwealth? Where can we see key elements of a new approach to monetary policy emerging today? read more


What’s wrong with markets, and why do we still need them? How does the Pluralist Commonwealth use markets to sustain communities? Where are examples of markets that remain subject to democratic control operative today? read more


What is liberty? Why must liberty be a central part of the design for the pluralist commonwealth? Where is a renewed conception of liberty being developed on the ground today? read more


Why is investment in the current system fundamentally undemocratic and unsustainable? How would a Pluralist Commonwealth democratize investment? Where is investment managed in more democratic directions today? read more


Why must we factor gender equity into the institutional design of the next political and economic system? What kinds of structures would a Pluralist Commonwealth use to support true gender equality? Where are important elements of a more gender equitable system being built today? read more

Evolutionary Reconstruction And Displacement

How do evolutionary reconstruction and displacement of corporate power differ from “countervailing” strategies of containment and regulation? Why are evolutionary reconstruction and displacement key strategic approaches in the building of a Pluralist Commonwealth? read more


Why is equality a key part of the Pluralist Commonwealth? How is movement towards equality achieved in the Pluralist Commonwealth? What examples prefigure equality as envisioned in the Pluralist Commonwealth? read more

Economic Growth

Why is growth a challenging problem? How Would the Pluralist Commonwealth Manage Growth? Where can we see on the ground efforts to tackle the growth question today? read more
Economic Change

Economic Change

How does economic change really occur locally and nationally? How, specifically, can we build upon the ways cities and states already foster the local economy to create the Pluralist Commonwealth? What are some examples of shifts toward greater democracy? read more

Ecological Sustainability

Why is pluralism necessary to guarantee ecologically sustainable ends? What are the key strategies for environmental protection in the Pluralist Commonwealth? What are some promising on the ground developments that point toward an ecologically sustainable Pluralist Commonwealth? read more


What is democracy? How does the Pluralist Commonwealth build stronger foundations for democratic life? Where are more participatory systemic directions being prototyped and developed today? read more


Why is decentralization a key principle of system design? What are the limits of decentralization? What are some contemporary developments in the direction of decentralization? read more


Why is culture a key part of the pluralist commonwealth? What are the most important strategies for building such a culture? What are some examples of the development of the cultural transformations toward democratic society at work today? read more


What are cooperatives? What role do cooperatives play in a Pluralist Commonwealth? Where else is this systemic direction for cooperatives being prototyped and explored today? read more


Why is community important to the pluralist commonwealth? What are institutional mechanisms aimed at undergirding rather than undermining community in a Pluralist Commonwealth? What current developments point towards the restoration of community as a central category? read more


What does it mean to hold wealth in common? Why is wealth held in common and democratized at various scales, so important for the design of a next system? What are some examples of how “common wealth” builds a “commonwealth” today? read more

Climate Change

What are the challenges presented by global climate change? How does the Pluralist Commonwealth tackle ecological threats such as climate change? What are some promising on the ground developments that point toward an ecologically sustainable Pluralist Commonwealth? read more


Why is bureaucracy problematic? What can be done in a pluralist commonwealth to minimize necessary bureaucracy? What contemporary interventions or potential interventions illustrate democratic control of large-scale entities? read more


Why is the Pluralist Commonwealth an American system? What resources for a Pluralist Commonwealth can be found in the American tradition? read more